• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Site-Logo
Phone 703-910-2600

Ten Six Consulting

Project and Earned Value Management, Primavera P6 & Deltek Cobra & Acumen Services

703-910-2600
  • Training Classes
    • Primavera P6 Training
    • Deltek Training
    • Earned Value Management Training
    • Project Management Training
    • Open Training Class Dates
  • Scheduling Services
  • Earned Value Mgmt. Services
    • RFP Support
    • Your EVM System
    • Certification
    • Data Analysis and Reporting
    • Post Contract Support
    • Staff Augmentation
    • WBS Guidelines for Government Acquisition Programs (MIL-STD 881D)
  • Tools
    • Primavera P6
      • Knowledge Transfer, Mentoring and Coaching
      • BI Publisher Services
    • Primavera Unifier
    • Deltek Cobra
      • Knowledge Transfer, Coaching and Mentoring
      • Staff Augmentation
    • Microsoft Project to Primavera P6 Conversion Services
    • Microsoft Project
      • Building an Integrated Master Schedule (IMS)
      • Integrating Microsoft Project with Deltek Cobra
      • Migrating From Microsoft Project To Oracle Primavera P6
  • Blog
    • Deltek Acumen
    • Deltek Cobra
    • Earned Value Mgmt
    • Microsoft Project
    • PMO
    • Primavera P6
    • Project Management
    • Risk Management
  • Clients
  • Contact Us
  • Training Classes
    • Primavera P6 Training
    • Deltek Training
    • Earned Value Management Training
    • Project Management Training
    • Open Training Class Dates
  • Scheduling Services
  • Earned Value Mgmt. Services
    • RFP Support
    • Your EVM System
    • Certification
    • Data Analysis and Reporting
    • Post Contract Support
    • Staff Augmentation
    • WBS Guidelines for Government Acquisition Programs (MIL-STD 881D)
  • Tools
    • Primavera P6
      • Knowledge Transfer, Mentoring and Coaching
      • BI Publisher Services
    • Primavera Unifier
    • Deltek Cobra
      • Knowledge Transfer, Coaching and Mentoring
      • Staff Augmentation
    • Microsoft Project to Primavera P6 Conversion Services
    • Microsoft Project
      • Building an Integrated Master Schedule (IMS)
      • Integrating Microsoft Project with Deltek Cobra
      • Migrating From Microsoft Project To Oracle Primavera P6
  • Blog
    • Deltek Acumen
    • Deltek Cobra
    • Earned Value Mgmt
    • Microsoft Project
    • PMO
    • Primavera P6
    • Project Management
    • Risk Management
  • Clients
  • Contact Us

Deltek Acumen and Critical Schedule Drivers

You are here: Home / Deltek Acumen / Deltek Acumen and Critical Schedule Drivers

June 16, 2021 By Ten Six

Deltek Acumen Critical Schedule DriversUsing the Critical Schedule Drivers feature in Deltek Acumen Risk

Critical paths have a way of shifting on you after risk adjusting your schedule. Deltek Acumen Risk provides a way to review all the probable risk adjusted critical paths.

Deltek Acumen performs a Monte Carlo analysis on the schedule to provide a risk adjusted analysis of your schedule. Acumen was originally developed by Acumen PM, an Austin, Texas based company founded by visionary leader Dr. Dan Patterson, PMP. Dan’s thesis regarding the critical path method (CPM) is that “until you have adjusted your project for risk, you don’t know what your critical activities are.”

In Deltek Acumen, each iteration of the Monte Carlo analysis computes its own critical path. You want to view critical paths and near critical paths that become critical due to risk. Acumen has a critical schedule drivers feature that displays all the schedule’s common risk adjusted critical paths, which is valuable information.

This article demonstrates the critical schedule drivers feature in Deltek Acumen Risk to inspect all the probable risk adjusted critical paths in the schedule.

We start below, in Figure 1, with our demonstration Primavera P6 Professional schedule.

Demonstration Primavera P6 Professional scheduleFigure 1

This is an Underground Pipe Branch Addition project schedule. If you inspect this schedule you will note that there are two main paths in the schedule. The non-critical path that includes procurement, and the critical path that includes excavation.

We want to include in our analysis the duration uncertainty for our schedule duration estimates, and risk events that may materialize during project execution. We therefore implement Deltek Acumen to risk adjust our schedule and perform a risk analysis. Shown in Figure 2, is our Underground Pipe Branch Addition schedule in Acumen S1 // Projects.

Example Schedule in Acumen S1 // ProjectsFigure 2

In Figure 3, we set the duration uncertainty of all activities in the project to very conservative.

Setting duration uncertainty of all activities in Acumen RiskFigure 3

A very conservative duration uncertainty means our duration estimates will be on schedule or better. In Figure 4 we have a list of our schedules risk events. Note, in particular, the Procurement Delay risk event, R3. It is probable that this procurement related risk event could place procurement activities on the critical path, after our schedule is risk adjusted.

Acumen List of schedules risk eventsFigure 4

In Figure 5, we set the Run Risk Analysis scenario to include uncertainty and risk events, but no mitigation.

Acumen Run Risk Analysis scenarioFigure 5

We proceed and perform the Monte Carlo risk analysis, Figure 6.

Acumen Monte Carlo risk analysisFigure 6

The histogram and S-curve results are displayed in Figure 7.

Deltek Acumen Risk histogram and S-curve resultsFigure 7

Well, the risk events had a meaningful impact on the risk adjusted model’s schedule Monte Carlo results. In fact, none of the Monte Carlo iterations met the deterministic project end date. This tells us that mitigation analysis to reduce the probability and impact of the risk events would be a helpful endeavor. But we also want to investigate the most common or probable critical paths.  For this we run an Acumen Critical Schedule Drivers analysis.

As mentioned above, each Monte Carlo simulation of the risk adjusted schedule may have a different critical path. So, activities that are critical in the deterministic model may not be the same as those identified in the statistical model.

As Acumen runs more simulations, some paths are repeated; it is the most common critical paths that we want to capture in our analysis. The Acumen Critical Schedule Driver feature uses a tornado chart to display the most common critical paths.

Each tornado plot bar displays a percentage, which is how often the path is critical in the risk adjusted Monte Carlo analysis. For example, if you run 1000 iterations and path 2 displays a percentage of 12%, it means path 2 was the critical path in 120 of the 1000 iterations.

We proceed in Figure 8 and choose the Critical Schedule Drivers feature to view critical paths and near-critical paths that become critical due to risk.

Selesctin Acumen Risk Critical Schedule Drivers featureFigure 8

In Figure 9 we have our Critical Schedule Drivers results. Path 1 appeared critical in simulations 84.4% of the time or 844 times out of 1000 iterations.

Deltek Acumen Critical Schedule Drivers resultsFigure 9

But we are not done yet. Another path appeared critical in our Critical Schedule Drivers tornado plot. A Path 2 appeared critical 15.6% of the time or 156 times out of 1000 iterations. Clearly Path 1 is the primary critical path, but Path 2 at 156 simulation iterations should not be disregarded.

In some situations, Path 2 could become the defining critical path of the risk adjusted schedule. It would be good, therefore, to at least consider the procurement risk event that contributes to Path 2 becoming the critical path in the schedule.

When we hover our mouse over Path 2, all the activities along this critical path display, Figure 10.

Acumen Hover to Display Critical ActivitiesFigure 10

Further, when we hover over Path 2 and right click the mouse, a popup menu appears providing the option to create a SmartGantt filter, Figure 11.

Acumen option to create a SmartGantt filterFigure 11

When we click Create SmartGantt filter the create filter dialog appears giving us the option to enter a name for the filter, Figure 12.

Acumen Create SmartGantt filterFigure 12

We enter a suitable name for our Path 2 procurement critical path, Figure 13.

Acumen Create FilterFigure 13

Then we proceed to S1 // Projects, Figure 14.

Acumen S1 // ProjectsFigure 14

Figure 15 displays the Pipe Branch Addition project schedule in S1 // Projects.

Acumen S1 // ProjectsFigure 15

Continuing we select Activity View | Filtering | Path #2 – Procurement, Figure 16.

Acumen Activity View | FilteringFigure 16

Now only those activities that appear on “Path #2 – Procurement” display in the S1 // Projects task table, Figure 17.

Acumen Projects task tableFigure 17

Summary

I repeat Dr. Dan Patterson’s mantra, “until you have adjusted your project for risk, you don’t know what your critical activities are.” And when you perform a Monte Carlo run risk analysis; each simulation may have a different critical path. As you run more simulations, some of the critical paths are repeated.

The objective is to capture the most common critical paths in a tornado plot. The Critical Schedule Drivers feature provides a tornado plot of these common critical paths. In this way the scheduler finds the most frequently occurring critical paths in the risk analysis that require attention, which again, is valuable information.

Further, in Acumen Risk you can display a list of activities on each critical path, and filter so only those activities on your respective critical path appear in S1 // Projects.

Primary Sidebar

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Categories

  • Deltek Acumen
  • Deltek Cobra
  • Earned Value Mgmt
  • Microsoft Project
  • PMO
  • Primavera P6
  • Project Management
  • Risk Management
CONTACT US

Footer

Upcoming Classes

Primavera P6 Professional Fundamentals
Primavera P6 EPPM Fundamentals
Primavera P6 EPPM Administrator
Primavera P6 BI Publisher Fundamentals
Deltek Cobra Fundamentals
Deltek Cobra Advanced
Deltek Acumen Fuse
Deltek Acumen Risk

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Consulting Services
  • About Ten Six
  • Contact Us
  • Blog

Copyright © 2023 Ten Six Consulting, LLC · 703.910.2600

  • Training Classes
    ▼
    • Primavera P6 Training
    • Deltek Training
    • Earned Value Management Training
    • Project Management Training
    • Open Training Class Dates
  • Scheduling Services
  • Earned Value Mgmt. Services
    ▼
    • RFP Support
    • Your EVM System
    • Certification
    • Data Analysis and Reporting
    • Post Contract Support
    • Staff Augmentation
    • WBS Guidelines for Government Acquisition Programs (MIL-STD 881D)
  • Tools
    ▼
    • Primavera P6
      ▼
      • Knowledge Transfer, Mentoring and Coaching
      • BI Publisher Services
    • Primavera Unifier
    • Deltek Cobra
      ▼
      • Knowledge Transfer, Coaching and Mentoring
      • Staff Augmentation
    • Microsoft Project to Primavera P6 Conversion Services
    • Microsoft Project
      ▼
      • Building an Integrated Master Schedule (IMS)
      • Integrating Microsoft Project with Deltek Cobra
      • Migrating From Microsoft Project To Oracle Primavera P6
  • Blog
    ▼
    • Deltek Acumen
    • Deltek Cobra
    • Earned Value Mgmt
    • Microsoft Project
    • PMO
    • Primavera P6
    • Project Management
    • Risk Management
  • Clients
  • Contact Us